When one partner is considering leaving, the other often feels blindsided, desperate, or confused. Marriage counselling can be a lifeline, but it also has limits.
Relationships rarely fall apart overnight. Small resentments, unresolved arguments, and emotional distance often build over time. By the time one partner expresses a desire to leave, the decision may feel final.
This imbalance (one partner ready to work while the other has checked out) creates unique challenges in counselling.
Related Article: 7 CBT Strategies Every Couple Should Try
What Marriage Counselling Can Do
Marriage counselling provides a safe, neutral environment where difficult conversations can take place. While therapy cannot guarantee reconciliation, it offers important benefits for both individuals and the relationship.
1. Create a Space for Honest Dialogue
Therapists help establish an environment where each partner feels heard. When emotions run high, discussions at home may turn into accusations or silence. In counselling, guided conversations allow both partners to voice concerns without fear of escalation.
2. Clarify Feelings and Intentions
Sometimes the partner who “wants out” is uncertain. Counselling can help them explore whether their doubts come from temporary frustration, unresolved conflict, or a deeper incompatibility. For the other partner, the process provides clarity about where the relationship truly stands.
Related Article: How to Improve Communication in Marriage: Best Practices from Experts
3. Improve Communication Skills
Even if the relationship does not survive, counselling equips partners with skills like active listening, expressing needs respectfully, and validating feelings. These tools reduce conflict during separation discussions and may support healthier future relationships.
4. Address Specific Relationship Struggles
Common issues include infidelity, emotional disconnection, or constant arguments. Counselling helps couples identify patterns, understand triggers, and practice strategies for rebuilding trust or managing conflict.
5. Offer Closure if Separation Occurs
If one partner remains firm in their decision to leave, therapy can ease the transition. Counselling helps couples part on respectful terms, especially important when children are involved. It allows both individuals to express their perspectives and reduce lingering resentment.
Related Article: 5 Relationship Issues CBT Can Solve
What Marriage Counselling Cannot Do
While counselling has many strengths, it is not a cure-all. Understanding its limits prevents unrealistic expectations.
1. It Cannot Force Commitment
No matter how skilled the therapist, they cannot make someone stay in a relationship against their will. Counselling can highlight reasons for reconnection, but the choice must come from both partners.
2. It Cannot Erase Past Hurts Overnight
Deep wounds, like betrayal or years of neglect, take time to heal. Therapy provides tools to work through pain, but forgiveness and trust are gradual processes that require consistent effort.
3. It Cannot Replace Individual Readiness
If one partner refuses to engage or dismisses the process, progress will stall. Counselling only works when both people are willing to reflect, take responsibility, and make changes.
4. It Cannot Guarantee “Happily Ever After”
Even couples who make progress may eventually decide to separate. Therapy is about exploration and growth, not about forcing a specific outcome.
Common Scenarios in Counselling When One Partner Wants Out
Every couple’s story is different, but several patterns often appear in therapy.
The “Leaning Out” Partner
One person feels disconnected and believes separation is the only option. They may attend sessions reluctantly, mainly to show they tried. In this case, therapy may still provide tools for a respectful breakup or, occasionally, spark reconsideration if underlying issues are addressed.
The “Leaning In” Partner
The other partner wants to save the marriage at all costs. Counselling helps them express their feelings without overwhelming their partner with pressure. It also supports them in preparing emotionally in case separation becomes unavoidable.
Mixed-Agenda Couples
When one is leaning out and the other is leaning in, therapists often use a process called discernment counselling. Unlike traditional marriage counselling, this short-term approach focuses on clarity: deciding whether to work on the relationship, separate, or continue in uncertainty for a defined time.
How Counsellors Support Couples in This Situation
Therapists at practices like Rosen Couples Counselling in Vaughan, Ontario, use proven methods to guide couples through these challenges. Their approach focuses on collaboration, ensuring both voices are heard and respected.
Counselling sessions often follow these steps:
- Assessment – Understanding each partner’s perspective and level of commitment.
- Goal Setting – Defining whether the goal is to repair, decide, or separate amicably.
- Skills Training – Teaching communication, conflict resolution, and empathy-building exercises.
- Evaluation – Checking progress, acknowledging breakthroughs, or identifying impasses.
These steps give structure to what can otherwise feel like a chaotic, painful experience.
Tools and Techniques That Help
Therapists employ strategies to keep discussions constructive and balanced.
- Active Listening: Partners repeat back what they hear, ensuring understanding.
- I-Statements: Shifting from “You always…” to “I feel…” reduces defensiveness.
- Validation: Recognizing each other’s emotions even without agreement.
- Time-Outs: Taking breaks during heated exchanges to cool down.
- Role Reversal: Temporarily stepping into the other’s perspective to build empathy.
These techniques can uncover hidden motivations and prevent conversations from spiralling into blame.
When Counselling Leads to Separation
Sometimes counselling confirms that separation is the healthiest path. While painful, therapy ensures that the process is handled with care.
- Managing Co-Parenting: Couples with children can establish ground rules, communication strategies, and parenting schedules in a supportive setting.
- Reducing Conflict: Instead of repeated arguments, counselling provides a structured forum for closure.
- Promoting Healing: Therapy helps individuals accept the end of the relationship and begin to rebuild their sense of self.
Related Article: How to Talk to Your Partner About Counselling
How to Approach Counselling if One Partner Wants Out
Entering counselling in this situation requires realistic expectations and emotional readiness.
- Acknowledge the Imbalance: Accept that you and your partner may have different goals.
- Stay Open to Outcomes: Therapy may save the marriage or help you separate respectfully.
- Commit to the Process: Even if it feels uncomfortable, attend sessions and practice skills at home.
- Seek Individual Support if Needed: Personal counselling can help process grief, anxiety, or anger.
The Value of Counselling Even Without Reconciliation
It is easy to view therapy as a failure if the relationship ends. In reality, counselling can still bring immense value. Partners often leave with:
- Better communication habits.
- Increased self-awareness.
- Tools for managing conflict in future relationships.
- Greater clarity about their values and needs.
These outcomes make the emotional investment worthwhile, even if the marriage does not continue.
Moving Forward with Compassion
When one partner wants out, both individuals face a painful and uncertain journey. Marriage counselling cannot reverse decisions already made in the heart, but it can provide understanding, dignity, and a path forward.
Whether reconciliation or respectful separation occurs, therapy gives couples the chance to approach this crossroads with compassion rather than hostility.
A Supportive Next Step
If you and your partner are in this situation, professional guidance can make all the difference. Rosen Couples Counselling offers a safe, supportive environment where both partners can explore their feelings, learn communication tools, and decide the best path forward. Evening and weekend sessions are available, and many insurance plans provide coverage.
Take the first step today by calling to book an appointment. A conversation with a professional could be the beginning of clarity, healing, and a healthier future whether together or apart.
